In the name of equality, stop!

Feminism.  No!  Don’t run away.  Let me explain.

The term ‘feminism’ has evolved over the last few decades.  Where once it was full of anger and seemed to pit man against woman, now it seems mostly to be a lot kinder.  Simply, reminding the world that women can do just as good a job as men, and vice versa.
I have been reminded lately that it has joined the other Isms of Equality (race, culture, disability, etc) and is threatening to join health and safety in the realms of Political Correctness Gone Mad.  What I mean is, my attention has been brought to stories that have a ‘token woman’.

Have you seen the Hobbit trailer for the Desolation of Smaug?  It looks amazing, until Legolas and Tauriel appear.  Why?  Well, Legolas doesn’t appear in the novel, although as his father does so I can just about put up with it.  Tauriel, however, is a completely new character.  She’s been created to bring a bit of balance to a very male heavy story, not to mention a spot of romance (with Legolas and/or Kili if the rumours are to be believed).
It almost, almost puts me off seeing the film.

Female characters, as with male characters and all setting, plot points and words in a story, should be there for a reason.  The reason should not be ‘to create romance’ or ‘so that women can relate to something’.  Not only is it demeaning but if the character shouldn’t be there, it’ll show.

There is not one female character in The Hobbit and for me, as a young women and fantasy lover, this isn’t a problem.  Yes, I love strong women, I always write about them and love reading about/watching them, but The Hobbit isn’t about strong women and that’s fine.  It’s about men; it speaks of post-war England and male attitudes.
Female viewers can enjoy a film wholly involving men just as much as one that involves men and women.

I particularly hate characters being included for a romantic element.  Just because we are women, doesn’t mean we need romance!  If I want to see romance, I will watch a romantic film.  When I watch a fantasy film, my mind isn’t particularly on romance.  When I watch the Hobbit, I want adventure and gold and dragons, not romance.

On the other hand, Tauriel is leading the wood elf army, so hurray for women in authority!  Unfortunately, the potential romance is with a prince, which requires the sick bucket to be brought back.

The Hobbit certainly isn’t the first, and won’t be the last, to receive this sort of treatment.

In 1997, someone decided it would be a good idea to give the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles a sister – Venus de Milo.  Apparently, there were five turtle babies in the sewers that came into contact with the radioactive ooze, but that clumsy Splinter missed one when he gathered them up.  When her adoptive father dies, she finds the turtles and emphasis is put on the fact that none of the turtles are related.  Thus, paving the way for a romance between Venus and one of the boys (I doubt they ever considered a romance between two of the boys).
Where did I put that sick bucket…

…I didn’t realise female turtles have breasts…

Venus is different to our fab four.  She hasn’t been trained in the art of Jujitsu, but she is a martial arts specialist so she can kick ass.  Unfortunately, she’s rather unworldly and seems to have had a sheltered childhood.  This gives the boys the upper hand, allowing them to ‘protect’ and ‘guide’ her.
Venus has since been deleted from the turtles’s history, although there are still clues to her existence.  When the TMNT were sold, Venus was removed amid the message ‘no female turtles!’.

I love the turtles.  I grew up on them, it’s the first thing my husband and I discovered we had in common.  I certainly didn’t need a female turtle to relate to them, and I doubt an unworldly, female turtle who is so different from the boys would help to instil a sense of strength and equality in a young girl.  It would be like suggesting that Bella Swan of Twilight fame could instil independence in young women and prove that they don’t need men to live a satisfying life.

Another example that really annoyed me was the introduction of Darby to the Winnie the Pooh franchise, although this isn’t quite the same.  It is entirely feasible that Christopher Robin grew up and moved on.  Much like Andy in Toy Story, bequeathing his beloved toys to a little girl (who has toy dinosaurs – I love her!).  Darby is a little red-headed tomboy, which I can relate to, being a bit of a red-headed tomboy myself.  Actually, my issue here is not with Darby.  I like her.  She’s brave and plucky and kind.  It’s more the fact that the makers felt they needed to replace a boy with a girl, or that they needed to change the working formula at all.

So sometimes putting a female character into a story isn’t such a bad idea, if the other elements are done correctly.  I can’t wait to see the Desolation of Smaug, but I do hope that Tauriel and Legolas don’t feature too heavily.

Are you looking forward to seeing Tauriel in the Hobbit?  Or can you think of any other examples of politically correct female characters?  I’d love to hear.

Advertisements

6 responses to “In the name of equality, stop!

  1. I find this kind of thing a bit annoying, too. They did the same with LOTR by giving the few female characters a much more prominent part than in the books. Not necessary! As you say, the book was written at a time when this was the norm – and the lack of strong female characters doesn’t make it bad. Sure, if it was written now things would be different (hopefully!) I prefer my classic stories to be left the way they are, thank you – and if that means male-dominated,so be it. 😉

  2. Definitely, I completely agree. If people change the traditional and classic stories then how will anyone learn from them. Changing LOTR and the Hobbit is like changing history and forgetting all of the post war and industrial revolution history that’s in there.
    Absolutely nowt wrong with the odd male dominated story anyway, we women are clever enough to find a way to relate 😉
    Someone pointed out to me today that kids are going to grow up thinking Winnie the Pooh has always been friends with a girl instead of Christopher Robin – made me very worried!!

    • Thanks Jon! I doubt it will ruin the film for me but getting a bit concerned with all the elf attention in the publicity! Fingers crossed it’s still a story about Bilbo and the dwarves.
      Strangely I really liked Radaghast being in the last film, probably because he’s not an elf…and didn’t take over!!
      Hope you’re doing ok 🙂

  3. Pingback: Forgiveness is divine, but never pay full price for late pizza | J E Nice·

  4. Pingback: A final trip to Middle Earth: The Battle of the Five Armies |·

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s